There seems to be a pattern of behaviour among some religiously devout folk. Some (and I cannot stress enough that this only applies to some) behave in a cruel, cowardly manner, and worse, seem committed to this behaviour, excusing themselves from even trying to be decent people. I could cite a plethora of examples, ranging from direct personal experience, observation of behaviour towards friends, and general observations from self-proclaimed good, pious Christians in positions of authority. I should add that my examples are not limited to Christians, but this particular example highlights the seemingly endless, cowardly cruelty of a self-professed Christian, who seems to believe their attitude is both righteous and excusable.

Revival Fires is the anonymous username of the person who has plagued Bruce Gerencser for years. At no stage has Revival offered anything looking even remotely like a coherent, honest, compassionate or compelling set of arguments to persuade Bruce (or his readers) that they should accept the Gospel into their hearts. If anything, Revival is an excellent case study in how to drive people away from Christ, and keep them away. When I challenged him on his abhorrent behaviour, suggesting he was being a poor example of a Christian, he replied thusly:

Ben Birddick,
There is no such thing as a “good Christian “. No one is good. All are depraved and in need of his grace.

As you can see, Revival doesn’t even wish to try and respect the teachings of the religion he claims to follow. He openly admits it. Instead, it appears he wishes to be as cruel, vindictive and hateful as he likes, and every now and then, at an arbitrary moment of his choosing, declares himself saved and forgiven. He has engineered himself a get-out-of-jail card. Instead of attempting to be virtuous and kind, Revival has chosen the opposite. Bruce has plenty to say on the subject, as you can see here.

Will he genuinely consider my words, or ponder how his behaviour reflects upon his religion? We shall see.

All of this certainly made me think. Why do people believe they can call themselves a follower of any given religion that preaches love, honesty, compassion and grace, and then proceed to completely dishonour those qualities? Do they believe that by declaring themselves to follow any given religion, they are automatically saved, or somehow automatically better than everyone else, even though their attitude does not show this? I’d love to understand the mindset of those who regard themselves as good, simply because of their faith, as opposed to those who actively try to be kind and respectful.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

A short and simple post here, and a question. Down the years, I have read many arguments for the notion of ‘God-given rights’. For some, rights and freedoms in society are dependent upon practicing religion. Of course, depending on who you talk to, those same rights and freedoms are dependent upon practicing the right faith 😏, and practicing that faith in the one true way.

Should our rights ever be reliant upon what we believe?

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

When I carried out the reset of Meerkat Musings, earlier in the year, I intended for it to be a clean break, in at least some respects, from what had come before. One area where this needs to happen is my ‘relationship’ with the author of Theology Archaeology, Mr David Thiessen. For nearly nine years, Mr Thiessen has harassed, defamed, and deceived, where me and my posts have been concerned. He has lied and distorted my work, and the work of others, to pursue a hate campaign. He will deny this, but the truth of my words can be found within his writings. In my last post, I pointed out that he deemed it acceptable to accuse me of wanting to murder Christians, or wanting to see Christians be murdered. In the past, Mr Thiessen has made it plain he has a ‘do as I say, not as I do’ attitude towards much of life.

There is no reasoning with a man who believes himself above everyone else, as Mr Thiessen clearly does. How else can a divorcee lecture others on what presents acceptable grounds for divorce? How else can a man who thinks intimidating and bullying his partner is not somehow a form of abuse, see fit to lecture others on what abuse looks like? How else can a man who fathers a child that he subsequently abandons speak of what it takes to be a good parent? How else can a man who commits social security fraud (whilst using fake identities) write about respecting the law? It takes some extraordinary cognitive disassociation to perform the mental gymnastics Mr Thiessen performs, but he nonetheless finds a way to insist he is absolutely right, and beyond question in all things, to the stage where his pretzel logic really is remarkable.

For the benefit of Insanity Bytes and Barabbas, you may find the following five posts, which contain at their heart a sworn deposition, featuring Mr Thiessen himself, insightful. P1, P2, P3, P4 and P5 all provide evidence that Mr Thiessen himself has not dared to challenge, though I am quite certain some form of hysterical response from him is inevitable, where he will cast vague assertions, without ever actually debunking a single line. They may want to ask him a few questions about his tendency to be cruel as well. It might be worth reviewing his belief that children should be forced to have children.

I left a comment on his latest display of petulance, but I suspect he will lack the courage or conviction to publish it, much less respond correctly:

I have no intention of going into 2025 wasting any further energy on this miscreant, hypocritical troll. I am confident that he has exposed himself for who and what he truly is.

Back to The Meerkat Responds

The other day, Mr David Thiessen of Theology Archaeology became so enraged by a factual statement, that he spoke of legal action against me. Well, he spoke of legal action against MM, not myself, for he remains too afraid of me to be professional, or honest.

I stated, over at Ark’s site, that Mr Thiessen holds women in contempt. I see no particular reason to retract my statement. Mr Thiessen’s attitude towards women has often been dubious at best. On the basis of Mr Thiessen’s comments, and indeed, spectacularly hypocritical actions, what reason do I have to reconsider my stance? He may wish to issue vague warnings, and speak of legal action, but first, he should check to make certain he is not holding a monkey’s paw. He has said, more than once, that women should not have bodily autonomy, even flippantly dismissing the risk of death to underage girls when they fall pregnant. He has repeatedly complained that ‘women lie’ regarding abuse and assault, yet also whined that women do not speak up about abuse and assault. He cannot seem to understand that his attitude – so readily casting doubt as to their motives – is a big part of why women do not come forward in the first place.

You need only look at his rage-fuelled rant about breast-feeding to get a clearer picture as to how he views women (one example of many). His fury that women might dare to act in the interests of their child, and not in his interests( hidden beneath claims of godly behaviour), is plain for all to see.

If he wishes to pursue legal action, then he ought to be aware that his dishonest implication I run a Nazi-esque comments policy will come under further scrutiny. Then there’s his false accusations here, where he claimed I was demanding things of him. I have the emails to prove otherwise. There are his repeated, yet always unsubstantiated claims that I distort his arguments. There was his strange, deceiving mileage he took from a very brief post I wrote when in a bad mood. There was the occasion that Mr Thiessen tried to imply I supported murdering Christians. Indeed, to quote him:

He apologised for this, but then removed that apology; by his own admission, apologising to me worked him into such a frenzy that he could not sleep! He claimed he did not recant his apology, but removing it would certainly imply a lack of sincerity on his part.

So, not only can I substantiate my claims, I can take Mr Thiessen to task for quite a few errant claims of his own, including some pretty serious assaults on my character. He is fortunate that he is not in an actionable set of circumstances, and fortunate that I am not particularly inclined to waste time and effort pursuing these matters.

Back to The Meerkat Responds

Having seen pertinent, overlapping topics come up via Bruce Gerencser (among others), I decided to offer my own thoughts, via the subject of individuality. These are tricky, challenging matters, and whilst I try to avoid distressing material, I cannot guarantee I’ll be able to avoid it here, so please bear that in mind before reading too far into this post.

The War on Individuality

Across a couple of sites, I have read conservative Christians warn of indoctrination, and I cannot help but find these warnings to be rather ironic. Organised religion is all about indoctrination and conformity. It is considered part of the mission of churches to spread the word, and to convince and encourage others to see the world through the same lens. Some particularly fundamentalist Christians fervently believe individuality should be crushed under conformist demands, demands that would erase the LGBT community from existence, and force everyone – including other Christians – to worship, and indeed think, in a particular manner.

One need only look at the language these fundamentalists use to demean anyone who does not think as they do. They call those who seek the same rights and freedoms as everyone else ‘bullies’. They refer to people who are transgender as sick and sinful. They in fact encourage a centuries-long trend of bullying and violence against anyone does not conform to their rigid ideology. ‘Live and let live’ is an alien concept to these fanatics. What’s worse is how they react when people reject the imposition of organised religion. They whine as to how they are being oppressed, though they cannot actually demonstrate any erosion of their own rights and freedoms.

The behaviour of those who claim to have an objective moral standard is often very much at odds with what most prudent people would seem decent. The wish to force conformity upon non-believers is rooted not in morality, but in fear, hate, and a desire for power.

Bodily Autonomy

So much of this war on individuality can be seen in the desire to control other people’s bodies. One need only take a cursory glance at how fanatics handle trans people. There has been much in the news lately about public bathrooms in the USA. Ignorant people have written misleading, whingy puff pieces about how trans people are sick and wrong. The religious right could direct people to tackle the meaningful problems of our age (such as climate change, and economic inequality), or they could look to handle the alarming number of pastors and preachers who commit sexual offences, but no, they focus on trans people as the major issue. They do this not out of love, but out of fear and revulsion, and they do not care about how damaging their words and deeds are. Trans people – alongside the rest of the LGBT community – are routinely demonised, ostracised, and treated in an appalling manner, for merely wanting to be themselves, without prejudice and judgement. It is often – and ironic too – the case that those who judge the LGBT community are of a woeful moral standard, the last people who have any right to judge others, and yet they wage war on the concept of bodily autonomy, out of rage and fear.

This can be see in how women are treated by religious fanatics. Women are often regarded as irrelevant. They are considered to be second-class citizens, whose bodies exist purely for the service of men. Some particularly cruel fanatics believe women should never, ever be believed when they speak of sexual assault, and some also believe that once women fall pregnant, it does not matter if they die or are crippled by pregnancy complications. This is because (in an ironic yet dishonest twist) the fanatics believe life is so important, the embryo takes precedence over the mother. The mother can be discarded, for she is just a woman, a vessel, and nothing more, in the eyes of these twisted people.

Controlling women has long been part of fanatic conservative religious discourse. There is a lengthy history of psychological manipulation, in the form of victim blaming/shaming. Women have been bartered via marriage for the benefit of power and wealth. The belief that women are property has gradually been overcome, but even today, some people have the impression that women should not have any authority over their own lives and bodies, that their lives only have meaning when serving the wants and needs of men.

Freedom, but only for Believers

Now, I am not suggesting that every Christian (or for the matter, every follower of every other faith) believes this, but it certainly seems that some feel rights and freedoms are conditional upon religious beliefs. Of course, even within Christianity (and for that matter, within other faiths), there is disagreement as to who the true believers are, which is as compelling as any a reason for why rights and freedoms should never be dependent upon one’s faith. Some might call this selfish (merely betraying their lack of English comprehension), but what is truly selfish is the demand that everyone conform to the ideals of any given religious belief. Freedom should never be conditional on religion. it is a pity some people think bullying and demeaning others into accepting this condition is somehow OK.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

It’s starting. Recently, Republican Representative Josh Schriver declared on Twitter of his desire to make same-sex marriage illegal again. Make no mistake, this is a sign, a signal if you will. The will is there, within the rank and file of Republicans and the Trump administration, to work toward eroding the rights and freedoms of anyone who is not a heterosexual, white, Christian American male.

Schriver himself is definitely approaching this from a Christian perspective, and tacitly expressing his wish to impose his beliefs upon anyone and everyone else. There is nothing to gained from stripping same-sex couples of their marriages, just as there is nothing to be gained from stripping anyone of their rights, yet this mentality is invasive. The LGBT community has had to fight for years for any measure of equality in what is meant to be a secular state, and now that equality is under threat from those who wish to turn the USA into a theocracy. I would say it is unlikely Schriver would see any measure of success in forcing his beliefs on others, but we are living in uncertain times.

It certainly seems that divisive and stifling ideas are coming to the fore.

The question that needs considering, as it so often does, is ‘why do the religious want to impose their beliefs?’ Why do conservatives seem so bent on curtailing the rights of those who do not affect them in any conceivable way? I am reminded of Bruce Gerencser’s post about persecution complexes. There seems to a fantasy with Christianity (some branches at least) where everyone must yield to Christian ways of thinking, regardless of their beliefs, and regardless of their rights. Any refusal to accept this imposition is then subject to much hand-wringing, and the implication that non-Christians not accepting Christianity somehow equates to persecution of Christians.

The key questions that I would put out there on this subject would be as follows:

  1. Is your life impacted by same-sex couples getting married? If so, how?
  2. Do you know anyone whose life has been negatively impacted by same-sex couples getting married, and if so, how?
  3. Can you provide any evidence that society is negatively impacted by same-sex marriage? Please provide sources and explanations.

I look forward to seeing some answers.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

Originally published in 2015. Edited and expanded. As of today, there is NO religious persecution in the United States. Every citizen is free to …

The Paranoia and Persecution Complex of Evangelical Christians

Written by Bruce Gerencser, here is a fascinating deep-dive into the oft-referenced, rarely-demonstrated Christian Persecution Complex. Christians – some of them at least – love to suggest they are being curtailed. Somehow, their voices are being diminished by society, the state, and who-knows-what else. Of course, they make these pronouncements in any and every avenue where they think they might be heard, including regional and national news, websites with a global reach, and all over social media. It’s true that being a Christian in some parts of the world brings more challenge than in others, just as being a Jew, Muslim, Sikh or Hindu can bring those same challenges. However, the thrust of Bruce’s post relates to the idea that American Christians are somehow facing persecution. I am struggling to think of any group that has so loudly screamed the message they are being silenced. I wonder if irony even exists in their language?

Back to Meerkat Reblogs

The second part of Mr David Thiessen’s illogical arguments relates once again to material of mine, that once again he is too cowardly to give proper attribution to. There is nothing much of any value in part two, save for this intriguing little nugget, that reveals a nice dose of Mr Thiessen’s hypocrisy, and pretzel logic:

If this is what Mr Thiessen believes (and this would certainly seem to be the case), then it shows his expectation that his Biblically-inspired mind has been shaped by Christian teachings to believe that men should have authority over women, which is the first step in seeing women as less worthy of respect and freedoms. Mr Thiessen goes on at length as to how women need to be protected, even going as far as to write:

Women are not weak, and in many respects are in fact the stronger. Women endure considerable physical and emotional changes during pregnancy. Women can multi-task to a superb degree, keeping a household in order whilst also working. Women have historically proven their strength countless times, and do not need protecting, least of all the sort of arrogant protection that Mr Thiessen, through his distorted lens of organised religion, would have us employ.

For the third and final part of Mr Thiessen’s Illogical Arguments, he chooses to to defend the notion that a woman’s body is not their own. He genuinely believes he has the right to tell women what they can and cannot do with their own bodies, perhaps motivated in part by a latent misogyny of his own. His willingness to regard women as inferior, as needing protecting, and as having no right to self-determination, has shone through across all three of his posts, ensuring that he has indeed written illogical arguments. It will be fascinating to see what further illogical positions he might hold.

Back to The Meerkat Responds

In my recent online travels, I have come across the same topic via a couple of very different sites. Ark is an atheist, and very-much opposed to organised religion. Barabbas is a Christian, and from what I can gather, quite passionately so. Both have presented posts on the matter of people being arrested outside an abortion clinic. Needless to say, Ark’s post and Barabbas’ post have very different takes on this subject.

It goes without saying that abortion is a difficult and challenging subject, and passions can run very high. A lot of people have very charged opinions, and powerful motivations behind their opinions. I am not going to get into this with this post, though it’s possible there will be some references.

Convicted for Praying?

This is the premise that a number of Christian sites and commentators have seized upon. They suggested what happened outside an abortion clinic in Bournemouth was a sign of erosion of freedom, specifically Christian freedom. Religious conservatives have long asserted their rights and freedoms are being eroded (rather ironically in my view), and this incident has provided fuel to their fire. However, what exactly happened?

Firstly, the gentleman in this case, Adam Smith-Connor, was not convicted of praying. This is a misleading claim, and a sensationalist one. It creates exciting headlines, but in the place of honesty. In 2022 the local council in Bournemouth introduced a a public space protection order around an abortion clinic. To quote part of the order (via The Independent):

“protesting… with respect to issues relating to abortion services”, whether approving or disapproving, and “includes but is not limited to graphic, verbal or written means, prayer or counselling”.

Note that the terms of this order are clearly spelled out, and prevent people from either side of this debate from encroaching upon the clinic. It also worth noting that this order was introduced after a public consultation.

In November 2022, Mr Smith-Connor took it upon himself to violate this order. He encroached upon an exclusion zone, and it’s my view that he did this despite knowing that the rules stated. He cannot have failed to be aware that his presence could be be construed as intimidating to people attending the clinic, but he did so anyway. What is of further interest here is that Mr Smith-Connor might have overlooked a Biblical instruction as well. Matthew 6:5:

“When you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men … but when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your father who is unseen.”

An Entitlement Complex

In a previous post of my own, I lamented my experiences with people intruding upon my personal space. These people are invariably religious, and they believe they have an absolute right to push their beliefs upon passers-by. This is not necessarily a breach of laws, but it is certainly a demonstration of an entitlement complex, and taken to an extreme, some of a religious persuasion believe their ‘moral’ authority outweighs the rules of the land. There appears to be a deeply-held notion that they can be above the law, if they believe the conditions are right.

This sort of entitlement spreads. Religious conservatives desire imposing their beliefs upon everyone they meet. They wish to involve themselves in the private lives of everyone, hence their interest in women’s bodies, same-sex relationships, and the trans community. They seek to control information, via book bans, and media manipulation. The sensationalist headlines regarding Mr Smith-Connor are a case in point. Often, political parties associated with the conversative right claim to be the parties of freedom, whereas in reality, they are the ones most interested in conformity, and in stifling the freedoms and expressions of anyone who does not share their values. They believe they have the right to do this.

Freedom from Consequences

Conservatives – well, some of them – operate under the idea that they should be free from any form of consequences for what they say and do. They hold to the idea that their freedoms are absolute, and that they should not face consequences for their actions, even when they knowingly disobey the law. The irony is that there is no such thing as absolute freedom. Many American religious conservatives will cite the 1st Amendment, but they have no right to walk into a crowded room and shout ‘bomb!’ They cannot incite violence, not without facing repercussions. Everything has some form of restriction, and that is often for the protection of others.

What religious conservatives desire is complete freedom, freedom to do what they please, at the expense of others if necessary. They believe they should face no consequences of any kind for their words, deeds and behaviour. After all, they believe they have an unquestionable moral right to do what they want. This is not how reality works, but it is something that they are working hard to sneak into society. They are trying to blur the lines between Church and State in the USA, and elsewhere in the world as well. With the encroachment of a theocracy, they can render themselves free from consequences, and without any apparent self-awareness, restrict the freedoms of those they do not agree with or approve of.

This is one of the reasons why tomorrow’s US Presidential Election is so vital. Conservatives would have you believe they are the party of freedom and individualism. They are in fact more interested in freedoms for those who share their beliefs, and more interested in conformity. Do not be fooled by their rhetoric.

Back to Deep Meerkat Thoughts

With inspiration from Ark’s post here, I examine the intrusive nature of organised religion.

I should add a disclaimer. Not everyone of a religious persuasion operates under the idea that they have a right to interfere in the lives of others. Unfortunately, not only to some believe they have an absolute right to involve themselves in the lives of others, they seek to invoke political support in order to do so. They also argue from a place of ‘moral’ duty. They have an unwavering faith in their beliefs, and in the moral authority their beliefs give them.

This gives rise to all sorts of shenanigans. As per Ark’s example, some Christians took up positions outside an abortion clinic, breaching a legal directive to stay away, so they could pray. Maybe it did not occur to them that their presence was intimidating to people attending the clinic (who would likely be stressed and emotional anyway), or maybe it did occur to them, but either way, they were defying the law, and in doing so, intruding upon the legal rights of others. Intriguingly, their actions appear to actually violate a Biblical instruction, namely Matthew 6:5:

“When you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men … but when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your father who is unseen.”

The clinic situation is an extreme example, but there are plenty of others.

I have been approached on the street, more than once, by people wishing to speak to me about God. If I wish to speak about God, I will seek out a church (or for that matter, a synagogue or mosque, among others), or I will seek out theologians to converse with. Approaching random people on the street is not, in my view, an appropriate gateway to religious discussion! To offer one particular example, once I asked a guy where to find a bank. He told me, and then proceeded to not only talk to me about God, Jesus, and religious beliefs, but he followed me through town as he did. I humoured him for a time, but when he started asking about my sex life (yes, seriously) I drew the conversation to a close.

If there is one defining difference between the religious and secular worlds, it’s that generally speaking, the secular world does not care what you do behind closed doors. If you are in same-sex relationship, trans, bi, black, white, religious, non-religious… none of it matters. You are generally free to be you. The religious world is not satisfied with that. They wish to impose their belief system upon everyone else. They want to get involved in who marries who. They demand a say in the private lives of others, and do not mind intruding upon the lives of others to get their message across. There is an entitlement complex here.

I can already predict the frothing-at-the-mouth responses from the peanut gallery. ‘Christians deserve a voice in politics too!’ Well, no one is saying otherwise. This is a classic example of a Red Herring argument, so to pre-empt it, let me say it again: no one is saying Christians cannot be involved in politics. What anyone entering into politics needs to understand is that you cannot freely trample on the rights of those who do not share your beliefs. Christians have no right to remove rights from others in a secular society. Unfortunately, whilst many Christians (and followers of other faiths) do understand this, others do not, and dogmatically cling to the idea that if they do not get their way over all of society, society is being unfair. Live and let live is a a concept beyond the ability of fanatics to understand.

Back to Deep Meerkat Thoughts