In the wake of a number of conversations with Citizen Tom, Derrick Thiessen of Theology Archaeology decided to wade in, and decided to argue in favour of a Christian Theocracy (well, that or a capitalist system, which betrays that Mr Thiessen does not understand capitalism is an economic system, not a political one, but I digress).

Derrick believes that a Christian theocracy would be superior to a democratic system. He argues – without specifics – that it would be better in terms of society, justice and mercy. However, this would only pan out to be true if everyone follows Biblical laws and instructions, something Derrick makes very clear:

There are no forced conversions or demands that everyone must be Christian to be a good American, Canadian, Russian, and so on. One freely chooses to obey the laws of theland or not. Those who choose the latter cannot complain because they know the penalties before they do the illegal act. They also know they will be punished correctly when caught.

In other words, if you are not following Christian rules, you will be punished. The theocracy will impose judgements upon you for wanting to live a life free from religious influence. This may be a utopia for Christians – well, Christians who worship and interpret the Bible precisely as Derrick does – but that’s about it. Derrick insists there would not be forced conversions, but if members of the LGBT community sudden have to hide who they are to satisfy the State, and risk punishment if they wish to be true to themselves, that pretty much is the expectation that everyone must be Christian (or pretend to be) to enjoy all the benefits of the State.

While this may sound like the coming of the false prophet and the one world leader, it is not. In that system, people are still persecuted and killed for not accepting the number of the beast. In the Christian theocratic system, people are not killed for not accepting the government’s stance.

They are only punished if they break actual laws. The upcoming one-world government will deprive people of life, liberty, and happiness, as shown by democratic, liberal, and socialistic/communistic governments of the 20th and 21st centuries, for just about anything.

Leviticus 20:10: ‘the man that committeth adultery with another man’s wife … the adulterer and the adulteress shall surely be put to death’, while Deuteronomy 22:22 thundered, if a man be found lying with a woman married to an husband, then both of them shall die’.

Derrick is a Biblical literalist. He believes that the Bible is 100% literally true, without question and without any room for any possible deviation. With that in mind, he would also therefore believe that adulterer’s should be put to death. This is an extreme form of punishment for a ‘crime’ that involves the private business of two or more adults. Adultery is obviously distasteful, but is it worth killing over? This is but one piece of evidence that a Christian theocracy would not favour life and liberty. It would in fact rob people of independence and the freedom to make their own personal choices, for fear of violent reprisals.

The only way that everyone gets to enjoy this ‘perfect’ society is if everyone acts and behaves the same.

False accusations by anyone, including the government, are curtailed, thoroughly examined, and the false accuser faces punishment instead of the innocent, who often have their lives ruined by these false accusations. Alleged crimes are not reported 20, 30, or 40 years later, but reported right away when the evidence is still in existence.

Someone’s word is not taken as evidence, nor is a group of people’s word taken as fact. Real, credible, legitimate evidence must accompany anyone’s complaint. Many people claim that a group’s unsubstantiated complaints are evidence of a crime, but that is not so.

This is one of the worst suggestions in Derrick’s entire post, and it’s unclear as to where this philosophy is enshrined in the Bible. It has been explained – in detail and as simply as possible – to Derrick why victims of abuse do not report it right away. Coercion, intimidation and manipulation are all tools of the abuser, and they are frequently wielded to silence victims and destroy evidence. If we adopted Derrick’s approach to this, Epstein would never have been arrested. There are scores of powerful people who have evaded scrutiny over sexual crimes for decades, because they have used their power, wealth and influence to scare victims into staying silent.

What also happens is that when victims do come forward early, they are often doubted. Derrick is fond of saying ‘women lie’. Well, men lie too, and will happily lie to protect themselves and other men, as evidenced on a large scale by the Epstein scandals. Taking the immediate policy of doubting victims who do come forward will not encourage them to come forward at any stage. There is also the question of how any of this part of Derrick’s argument is actually relevant or Biblical, in relation to a theocracy.

There’s another problem. Derrick is a Bible literalist. Let’s say he is the ruler of this government, and ensures those writing laws and policies do so under his instruction to treat the Bible literally. What happens when Derrick is gone? The next ruler will interpret the Bible differently, as will the next, and the next, and the next. Despite Derrick’s frequent protests to the contrary, the Bible is subject to interpretation, as witnessed by countless scholars arguing about it for centuries. It is inevitable that someone will inherit leadership of this theocracy that does not share Derrick’s interpretation. Theocracies are subject to the whim of the rulerS.

Theocracies also do not represent everyone living within their borders. Consider the unrest in Iran, a theocracy in all-but name. Derrick may protest that Iran is an Islamic theocracy than a Christian one, but the same basic problems will emerge under any theocracy. A Christian theocracy requires that everyone obeys Biblical law, as filtered (in this instance) through Derrick’s personal interpretation of the Bible. What will happen to people who do not share Derrick’s values? What rights to expression will they have, if any? Theocracy might as well be a fluffy term for dictatorship. The end result is certainly the same.

I await Derrick’s thoughtful and constructive response.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

With apologies for the lengthy title, and with thanks to the evergreen Bruce Gerencser for providing the inspiration, in this post I’m delving into a murky realm, a place where facts meet with dogma, and the evidence around is challenged not by additional evidence, but with the unreliable element of human interpretation.

Bruce’s post highlights the problem of unhinged fanaticism overriding evidence and logic, and what’s worse, this was used to unreasonably persecute a teaching assistant who merely graded a student in accordance with the requirements of the test. The student had not followed guidelines and subsequently failed the test, but did not accept this outcome, protested under the unreasonable lines of ‘religious persecution’, and got the instructor suspended as a result. There is a serious case of entitlement on show here, and unfortunately this is far from an isolated case.

The expectation that facts should give way to indoctrination is not a problem unique to organised religion, but you can bet that organised religion is one of the chief driving forces behind eroding common sense educational needs, and it is certainly among the most powerful movements aimed at undermining good science. I have written before of the desire of some Christians to replace logic-driven, evidence-based teachings with rigid, literal interpretations of holy texts, and these rather close-minded fundamentalists do not stop to consider the cost of this. If we had kept to such blind devotion, humanity would never have escaped the Stone Age.

Our willingness to challenge, to learn, to observe and to study is why we have longer lifespans than ever before. It’s why we can survive injuries and illnesses that would have inevitably killed our ancestors. Now, some people might say ‘but you still can’t cheat death!’, but that would be beside the point. I am not saying we can render ourselves immortal and turn back entropy. However, that has nothing to do with how we are better placed to fight diseases and injuries.

Quality of life has improved too. If not for a willingness to learn, we would never have developed tools to make growing and preserving food easier. It would still take days to travel across a country, and weeks or months to travel between continents, assuming we could safely make the journey. What makes this all the more ironic is that the very people who are loudly decrying science, and bemoaning persecution, enjoy all the fruits of science, yet as sure as night follows day they will list out anything negative they can think of, without pausing to reflect that they throw the baby out with the bathwater in their little rants.

Can scientific endeavour be used for harm? Yes. Is that a reflection on science itself? No. What would do far more harm is to encourage deception in education. Letting irrelevant answers with no relevance to the topic take precedence over facts, logic and evidence does a lot more damage to our progress as a species, and to then whine of persecution? The irony is high, and the lack of self-awareness is even greater. You have to shake your head in disbelief at the cognitive disassociation on display.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

Sympathy and empathy are two qualities that I sometimes fear are becoming increasingly absent from the human condition. To have sympathy is to have ‘feelings of pity and sorrow for someone else’s misfortune’. To have empathy is to have ‘the ability to understand and share the feelings of another’.

These traits are important. They help to define humanity, and they bring out the best in us. When sympathy and empathy are absent, we see the worst of humanity. I know of people – sadly a great many people – for whom sympathy and empathy are hindrances. This is most obvious when discussing matters like immigration, poverty, healthcare and bigotry, though it can be apparent in other walks of life as well.

One of the more unsavoury skills humans possess is the ability to ‘other’ those who are different. If their skin colour is different, or their language, culture, or economic background is somehow deemed undesirable, we tend to take a dim view of their plight. If we find the individual or group more palatable, we treat them better. Our empathy and sympathy, indeed sometimes just our general treatment of people, should not be dependent on their appearance, faith or creed, but to listen to far-right commentators, looks matter more than substance.

Hate dressed as Love

A lack of true sympathy and empathy is never rendered more obvious than when those of a deeply conservative religious persuasion start talking about the LGBT community. They claim to speak the truth with love, yet fail to consider how damaging it is to call people ‘abominations’, and how hurtful and demeaning it is to refer to them as abnormal, sinful (which is irrelevant to most in the LGBT community, since most don’t believe in the concept), and wrong. At no step do these commentators pause to reflect on their choice of language, nor on how their demands over policy will do real harm.

What matters more to the religious right is getting their way. They are often so wrapped in dogma and indoctrination that they cannot conceive of anything other than their own righteousness. Love, compassion, sympathy, kindness… they distort the truth of these words into something grotesque and harmful, and they can’t or won’t comprehend how harmful their rhetoric and language is.

This is not an issue limited to the LGBT community. Women face prejudice for similar reasons. In various parts of the world, and often (not exclusively, but often) down to rigid interpretations of organised religion, women have their rights and freedoms curtailed. Instead of empathy and understanding, women are denied bodily autonomy, for they are seen as vassals and property. A lack of sympathy and true compassion has reduced women to second-class citizens in the eyes of some, expendable and irrelevant.

We can expand this still further. There is a furore over immigration, generated by the cold rank and file of the elite and the powerful to distract from real problems. The hard-right pushes the narrative that the unkempt immigrant is dangerous, greedy and lazy, and out to destroy western culture, whilst desiring us to overlook the true source of greed and inequality. They want people to be divided, and they seek to cultivate a lack of empathy to further this agenda. Unfortunately, it is a highly-effective scare tactic.

What society needs is to see the individual, and to hear their story. I have neighbours who are immigrants, and they are among the loveliest people I could know. They have always been friendly and they have often lent me a hand with one thing or another. I have a female boss at work, and this is not the first time this has been the case. I have worked with members of the LGBT community. Nothing good would have come from ‘othering’ them, or from treating them any differently to how I treat anyone else. See the person, hear their story, remember they are an individual, and show some true sympathy and empathy for what they have been through. It’s not difficult.

Back to Meerkat Prompts

Time for a Meerkat Reblog, albeit Meerkat Musings can be most unfriendly to WordPress’s reblog function! With that in mind, I am instead linking to yet another excellent post from my friend Bruce Gerencser. Bruce himself references a post by Caroline Bologna at the Huffington Post, which discusses the interesting phenomenon of vertical morality.

Below, I reproduce the post Bruce shared, for it is certainly illuminating as to why some Christians play so fast and loose with the principles they demand of others.

Caroline Bologna writes:

For many Americans, the gap between Christian teachings and MAGA politics is baffling. How can people profess faith in Jesus ― who preached love, mercy and care for the oppressed ― while supporting policies that punish immigrants, demonize LGBTQ people and glorify cruelty?

The key to understanding this apparent contradiction might lie in something called “vertical morality.”

This ethical framework measures righteousness not by goodness to others, but by something more simplistic. Below, Christian advocates and former fundamentalists break down what vertical morality means and how it explains our political landscape today.

….

“Vertical morality teaches that authority, power and a moral code of right and wrong, or acceptable and unacceptable, come from ‘above’ ― an external superior who designates rules, systems and tenets that must be obeyed by those beneath,” said Tia Levings, a former Christian fundamentalist and author of “A Well-Trained Wife: My Escape from Christian Patriarchy.”

In the context of religion, the superior is God. In politics, it might be an authoritarian dictator. In a cult, it would be the controlling leader. Whatever the circumstances, the idea is that behaviors are only right or wrong based on what the figure in power says.

“Vertical morality in Christianity is the idea that our ethics and behaviors have a duty to please God alone. We get our morals from God and we must obey him, furthering the will of God no matter the cost,” said April Ajoy, author of “Star-Spangled Jesus: Leaving Christian Nationalism and Finding A True Faith.”

….

“Vertical morality is just how I describe what’s called ‘divine command theory’ in metaethics,” she said. “I’m a teacher, so I’m always looking for ways to make complicated concepts a little more simple. It’s basically the idea that morality comes from authority above, which is what I was taught when I was raised within conservative Christianity.” [Rachel Klinger King]

Vertical morality stands in contrast to the concept of horizontal morality, another term Klinger Cain has broken down in her videos. 

“Horizontal morality prioritizes the well-being of our neighbors, communities and personal relationships,” Ajoy explained. “We act in ways that cause the least amount of harm to those around us, regardless of beliefs. Someone with vertical morality may help someone in need because they believe that’s what God wants them to do, versus someone with horizontal morality may help that same person for the benefit of the person that needs help.”

Rather than unquestioning obedience and superficial optics, this approach focuses on genuine empathy, compassion, and love toward others, recognizing the actual effects our actions have on people.

….

In Matthew 25, Jesus describes people who fed and clothed those in need, who welcomed the stranger, who took care of the sick and visited those in prison,” she noted. “He then says, ‘What you did for the least of these, you did for me.’ He equates loving our neighbors (horizontal morality) with loving Christ (vertical morality).” [April Ajoy]

….

“Evangelicals are taught that all morality comes from God and therefore true goodness can only be spread by obeying God, even if it harms people around us,” Ajoy said. “This isn’t necessarily a bad thing if pleasing God manifests by following the teachings of Jesus ― loving our neighbors, loving our enemies, promoting peace and taking care of the poor, the widow, the immigrant and standing up for the marginalized. It becomes dangerous when Christians weaponize this vertical morality for power, which is exactly what we’re seeing with the Christian nationalism in the Trump administration.” [April Ajoy]

“What’s interesting is that Jesus taught a compassionate, flexible, grace-filled view of what it means to live a life loving God,” Levings noted. “But today’s conservative Christianity is less influenced by Jesus and more by the Old Testament and Paul.”

She pointed to theonomy, the belief that Old Testament laws should be applied to modern society, as an influence on Christian nationalist politics.

ummarizing the role of vertical morality in the Old Testament, Klinger Cain highlighted the story of Abraham, who was commended for his willingness to obey God’s command to sacrifice his son Isaac, despite the act’s inherent immorality.

“What should happen if you have a horizontal moral system is, you should go, ‘I’m not murdering someone, even if an authority figure has told me to do that,’” she said. “But under vertical morality, that would be a sin because you’re disobeying God.”

Drawing from the most violent and extreme chapters of Biblical history, this approach frames unquestioning obedience as the highest virtue, even when it demands actions that defy compassion or common sense. And what might’ve once been a religious debate has now become a broader cultural conflict thanks to the role of conservative Christians in writing Project 2025 and otherwise shaping public policy.

“The problem with MAGA Christians is that they promote policies that often go against the teachings of Jesus,” Ajoy said. “They justify it by promoting a view of God that is vengeful. They demonize all immigrants as criminals, all queer people as predators, all leftists as violent and all Democrats as satanic ― with no evidence to back these claims. And because they believe in a literal hell and a God-ordained calling to make the nation Christian, they justify cruelty in the name of ‘tough love.’”

Under a vertical moral system, the worst thing you can do is disobey God’s laws, and this perspective has bled into politics as well. Klinger Cain offered the example of the rather callous response to “Alligator Alcatraz” and the extremely punitive treatment of immigrant detainees from MAGA Christians.

“On one side, we’re looking at people who are undocumented, so yes, they’ve broken a rule. But for the most part, there are no victims ― so why is our government being so harsh?” she said. “But the other side, with this fundamental Christian worldview, sees every broken rule as deserving a super harsh punishment. You don’t have to be a murderer or a rapist to go to hell. Every broken rule leads to hell ― even just taking a bite of an apple cursed all of humanity.”

This religious viewpoint desensitizes people, so inhumane immigrant detention feels fine and deserved. Klinger Cain added that, for people with this perspective, the only way to escape the fate of hell is not through good actions but simply by being on the right God-ordained MAGA team.

“Vertical morality has caused white conservative, MAGA-aligned Christianity to completely abandon the core of Christ’s teachings because their focus is on self-interest and perceived moral purity,” Hale said. “To them, they are Christians and haven’t abandoned the faith at all, but their framework measures righteousness in a way that can excuse behaviors that the general public knows and sees aren’t Christlike at all.”

This system also demonizes empathy. Some conservative authors have even written books describing empathy as sinful or “toxic.”

“If Abraham had empathized too much with his son and chosen not to kill him, then that empathy would have been a sin,” Klinger Cain said. “We’ve seen this concept play out in Christianity with pastors telling parents not to allow their children to be gay, even if it hurts them. The idea is don’t allow your empathy to support sin in this way.”

….

“Vertical morality feels safe in chaotic times, when ‘figuring things out’ or ‘learning from past mistakes’ feels daunting,” Levings said. “It’s also easier to comply with when the bottom-dwelling citizens feel like they have little power or agency to resist an authoritarian system. Sometimes, compliance is a matter of survival, and agreeing with it is a necessary means of getting along and staying safe.”

Hale agreed that vertical morality feels easier and less complicated than actually confronting systemic issues and the complexities of social justice. 

“It’s easy to measure your faith by private devotion or rules that you think are in the bible, rather than by how you show up in the world,” she said. “The unfortunate part is that it can blind people to injustice and sometimes cause them to justify harmful behavior. When your focus is on individual righteousness rather than collective responsibility, you don’t learn how to show up for others ― you only care about your own journey.”

As a result, Hale added, you risk fostering a society where people aren’t held accountable for harmful actions and can be cruel and exclusionary, as long as they are “good Christians.” Rather than social responsibility, it’s all about personal salvation.

“We’re seeing vertical morality weaponized today in the Trump administration,” Ajoy said. “If they can convince people that they are ‘of God,’ then it doesn’t matter who they hurt in the process. They say Christian things. They quote scripture. But they are wreaking havoc on the very people Jesus calls us to love and care for. It reminds me of another verse in Matthew 15 that says, ‘These people honor me with their lips, but their hearts are far from me.’”

“Vertical morality can’t take into consideration modern advancements or needs, evidence of failures, new research and information and human progress in civilization,” she explained. “Those with a vertical structure aren’t inclusive or accepting of other worldviews. Diversity can’t exist because it threatens the high contrast right-wrong rigidity found in fundamentalist authoritarianism.”

Some interesting food for thought.

Back to Meerkat Reblogs

Not for the first time, I am drawn to the words – and wisdom – of Soatok, of Dhole Moments. His latest post, ‘Furries Need to Learn that Sunlight is the Best Disinfectant‘, is a demonstration of how a community can grow, learn, and tackle the murkier side of its existence. There are those within the furry community who have defended the indefensible, and there are those who are more worried about the damage to image by bringing these miscreants and abusers into the light. This might sound very familiar, because it is. The furry community is often maligned or dismissed as being all about deviancy, and yet, for centuries, a much older group has been complicit in various acts of cruel depravity, and this group has gone out of its way to cover up all sorts of awful crimes.

Fursuit… or Black Collar?

Below are 10 examples of a community embroiled in sexual assault cases, including several against children. Before you click on the links, ask yourself, how many relate to furries, and how many relate to fundamentalist religious leaders?

One, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight, nine, ten

If you do not want to click the links, I’ll save you the trouble: each one of those 10 examples will take you to Bruce Gerencser’s Black Collar Crime series. That’s right, each example relates to a different religious leader, across various parts of the USA, though what they have in common is that they all occupied a position of trust and authority within their communities, and they all violated that trust. They used their standing to commit awful crimes, and in various cases got away with it for years, perhaps decades, because they used their power to control the narrative. They used the respect of their position to cover up their misdeeds.

This is not to say that furries – or indeed any other group – are incapable of similar behaviour. Wherever people have power or authority, there is the risk of abusing it. There have been high-profile scandals involving beloved BBC presenters. The rank and file of big business and high politics have a lot to answer to regarding Jeffrey Epstein, whilst Harvey Weinstein abused his position with the film industry. In all these instances, the rich and powerful have supported the rich and powerful in restricting the flow of information, suppressing victims, and making sure to hide the truth. In the case of the elements of the furry community, there is at least a sign that they are capable of self-policing. The others? Well, possibly, albeit at a glacial pace.

Guilt by Reputation

Furries are often presented as overly sexualised, and there is an element of this to the community, but then again, in the vast majority of occasions it’s all about consensual relationships. People love to make assumptions, but assumptions make an ass out of you and me, and all too often, those pointing the finger of disapproval need to reflect on the behaviour of their own ilk. Society faces more ills from organised religion, institutionalised patriarchal practices, and unchecked greed, than it could ever face from people who dress up as anthropomorphic animals. Alas, the powerful are always looking for scapegoats, and they are keen to distract from their own failures. They seize on the worst examples (some of which aren’t even remotely true), whilst covering up their own horrendous crimes.

You have to wonder who the next scapegoats will be. You also have to wonder if the rich and powerful will ever truly try to clean up their own messes.

Back to The Thinking’ Kat

The WordPress Prompt of the Day offered this one, and it was too interesting to pass up.

The short answer is no. The long answer remain no, because organised religion holds no appeal to me. Virtually every version of every major religion is incompatible with my morals and values. This is not to say that there aren’t some good elements to religion, because there are, but all too often the general message is ‘without total obedience, you will be condemned to an eternity of suffering’. That ain’t an especially great means of encouraging the ‘right’ behaviour (whatever that is).

My viewpoint has also been shaped by some unpleasant experiences with the devout. I have been harassed, lied about, and demeaned by so-called pious men of God. They display their hypocrisy in their cruelty, and then act as though they can wave away their antics by uttering a prayer, or speaking of their faith, as though that absolves them of their wrongdoing. This sort of ‘get out of jail card’ is lazy, and lacking in integrity. It grants the means to avoid responsibility for anything.

Then there is the social side of things. My encounters with fanatics have taught me that they believe only they have a right to a voice. Only the religious should be allowed to shape society, to represent it, to share opinions and beliefs. I have seen some spectacular whinging whenever someone of the LGBT community offers up their views. You’d think that the religious were being rounded up in camps and held at gunpoint, every time any group they don’t like exercises their right to speak! This epic double-standard has further eroded my… let’s ironically call it faith, that organised religion is a good force for society.

This is not to say that it’s all bad. The community my wife and I discovered during the reading of our wedding bands is among the kindest I have ever found. This small Church held its doors open for anyone, and offered nothing but love and respect to those who walked through them. There was no firebrand preaching, instead the sermons were regularly about showing each other compassion. This is a trait sorely missing among the fanatics I have dealt with down the years.

I should make it clear, my experiences are not limited to Christianity. I have encountered pleasant Muslims, and cruel Muslims. One particular individual might as well be the Muslim equivalent of the long-term Christian troll I’ve been dealing with. It seems that dishonesty and cowardice are traits that cross religious boundaries, so to speak. These people have no idea to interact with others, and certainly fail to persuade me that their belief system is worth converting to. If anything, the aggressive posturing fanatics are leaving me secure in my choice not to follow organised religion.

Back to Meerkat Prompts

In one of my recent posts, I referred to a post by my buddy Bruce Gerencser, and the question put to him by one Dr Arv Edgeworth. This got me thinking about the wider context, or certainly a possible wider context. There have been a number of objections to Bruce’s Black Collar Series, and also objections to him telling the story of his de-conversion. Indeed, to listen to the conservative religious right, there are a great many complaints about anyone who is not a deeply religious conservative having any sort of voice.

In the eyes of these people, it is selfish for anyone they don’t agree with to speak. It is selfish of them to wish to have the same freedoms as the devout. It doesn’t matter that no one is impeding the religious conservative, it doesn’t matter that they can still do all the things they usually do, if anyone who is not of their ilk dares to speak, to share their views and opinions, that is apparently a selfish act. How dare someone who doesn’t adhere to the rigid conformity of the conservative religious right have a voice in society! It’s obscene to them, so they do whatever they can to impede the rights of others.

In the case of Dr Edgeworth, he is clearly worried that Bruce’s voice might sway people from the flock. The introduction of an individual line of reasoning, a person sharing their unique and personal experiences, is a danger to the uniformity the religious right craves for the sake of power. People are less-easily coerced when they think for themselves. It’s intriguing that a pastor often refers to their congregation as a flock, because a flock of like-minded, easily-controlled sheep is what a lot of conservatives desire.

It isn’t selfish to tell one’s story. It is not selfish to share one’s experiences and beliefs. It’s not selfish to desire equality. The ones who are telling you otherwise are the selfish ones, who desire power and control, and you will usually find this attitude is prevalent among the religious right, more so than elsewhere. These are the ones who want anyone they don’t agree with to be silent, and in some cases, they are prepared to be manipulative, and even nasty, to gain that silence. Resist this attitude, don’t be a sheep!

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

Of late, my friend Bruce Gerencser has been in conversation with a Christian, by the name of Dr Arv Edgeworth. Dr Edgeworth has sent Bruce a number of emails, emails which typically follow the pattern of most diehard Evangelicals. Dr Edgeworth’s latest email to Bruce struck me as a rather strange attempt to draw equivalence between sexual ‘misconduct’, and spiritual ‘misconduct’. This email relates to Bruce’s long-running Black Collar Crime Series, a series which brings the alleged crimes of pastors and preachers to light.

This isn’t the first time that people have tried to minimise the impact of sexual assault. It’s not the first time that supposedly learned men of faith have tried to play it down. The effect of sexual violence is going to differ from person to person, but generally speaking it leaves life-long scars, well beyond the immediate physical trauma. Deep, emotional and psychological wounds from these terrible events will loiter in the consciousness of the victims for decades, even if they manage to get a conviction against their attacker (which remains a big if). Dr Edgeworth wants us to think of the spiritual, well, how about the ‘spiritual’ damage done to the victims of sexual assault, especially when their attackers are seemingly upstanding pillars of society, who use their position to escape responsibility from their actions?

Pastors are generally respected within their communities. There are many examples of them exploiting and abusing their status to commit and cover up crimes. From the instant they assault someone, they and their cohorts close ranks, rendering the suggestion of impropriety outrageous, whilst manoeuvring to disguise or destroy evidence. Victims are bullied, coerced and threatened into silence. Sometimes, after years or decades of bottling up shame, rage and fear, they will come forward, though by then it can be very hard to get justice.

What doesn’t help is that some ignorant people whine when victims come forward. ‘Why did you wait so long?’ Their derisive response to someone plucking up the courage to face what happened to them is one of the reasons why some people never come forward. These same whingers decry at the time that the victims can be lying. Yes, sometimes people lie about being assaulted, but people also lie about carrying out assault! Indeed, a lot of convicted criminals – including those of the clergy – will have previously lied, denied, and evaded talk of their crimes. If it is reasonable to practice innocent until proven guilty, it is reasonable to extend the benefit of the doubt to those who claim to have been assaulted.

As to whether or not spiritual misconduct is worse, what does that even mean? If a pastor has a change of heart and leaves Christianity, that is their right. The last time I checked, people have free will, and the right to follow what they believe. If that pastor’s story is capable of shaking the beliefs of others, is that the fault of the story? Or does it speak to something else? There is an expression, ‘if it can be destroyed by the truth, it deserves to be’. To paraphrase that, if your faith can be destroyed by someone speaking honestly and plainly of their experiences within it, perhaps it deserves to be. It is also not a question of ‘misconduct’. Why can’t someone share their negative experience of religion? What makes religion immune to criticism? Nothing should be immune from criticism.

If you believe in everlasting consequences for the soul via de-converting, that is up to you. I for one am more concerned with the damage done by lying pastors, who have used their position of respect and authority to get away with some awful crimes.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

I had barely posted my allegory about tea when it swiftly became apparent the point of my post had been spectacularly missed. To offer an explanation that is hopefully clearer (perhaps bordering on child-like, we shall see), let me break it down.

Both the tea-seller and their desired customer are in the public domain. Does this grant the seller the right to relentlessly pursue their desired customer, especially in an aggressive, nasty manner, and especially after the customer has said thanks, but no thanks?

When I wrote my post, it was aimed at Revival Fires, an individual who has trolled Bruce Gerencser for years. Revival Fires appears to operate with a determined righteous, going as far as to use this to justify his cruelty and cowardice. However, Revival Fires is far from alone in his attitude. The brilliant Rawi mentioned the concept of unsolicited advice, and it is certainly true that diehard Evangelicals – among others of a passionate religious stance – operate with this principle. They believe that their rights trump those of others, and that they should be free to preach at others, even against their wishes.

Of course, if one is free to preach in the public sphere without restraint (and seemingly without grace, kindness or compassion), then one must accept the consequences of that. You cannot be… let’s say boisterous in your manner, and act surprised if your attitude backfires. Viciously berating others in public for not accepting your beliefs, long after they have asked you to leave them alone, will not create an environment conducive to civil or constructive discourse. If you want people to hear you and take you seriously, perhaps try being respectful in the first instance, and if they still do not wish to hear you, back off. After all, would you, as a tea seller, appreciate someone hounding you to reject your tea, and try coffee instead? Especially if they preached fire and brimstone at you?

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

Picture the scene. You are running a drinks stand, and you offer a passer-by a cup of tea. The person politely refuses. What should happen next is that you accept this. However, you firmly believe, without a shadow of a doubt, that this person needs a cup of tea. You walk after them, speaking of the benefits of tea. They politely refuse again, a touch of irritation in their voice. It is clear they do not wish for tea. What should you do now?

A reasonable person acknowledges the person’s preference, and moves on. You don’t. You’re getting irate, remonstrating with your reluctant customer that they are being foolish and ignorant by not at least trying your tea. ‘I’ve had tea before, and I didn’t like it, please stop offering it,’ they urge you. ‘Well, this tea isn’t like other tea, it’s better, I know it is, it’s superior to other teas, it will definitely do you a world of good, stop being foolish and ignorant by not trying it.’

It should not come as a surprise that your combative attitude has raised the hackles of your would-be customer. They are now a combination of perplexed and annoyed, wondering why you are pursuing them, and baffled by how you believe your aggressive stance will persuade them that your tea is somehow better than anyone else’s, even if they drunk the stuff.

‘If you don’t drink this tea, your health will suffer, and you will die,’ you claim. Their eyes widen, a mixture of shock and fury on their faces. Incredulity is the buzzword now. You are now furious yourself. You cannot believe this person will not even try your tea! You absolutely know your tea is better than the other teas this fool has tried, and you now make that clear to them, as well as how much of a fool they are for not trusting you or your tea. You berate them, all in the name of opening their eyes to the glory of your tea, unable to understand why they can’t comprehend the obvious.

What you should do is back off. This person is not interested, and you are clearly annoying them. Engaging with them is also aggravating you, so it’s a lose-lose scenario, yet you feel compelled to continue to force your tea at them. You still fail to understand their inability to grasp what you know, and you cannot understand why they are not cowing and bowing to your righteous fury. You make it your mission to make this idiot understand why your tea is so great, turning this into your personal crusade. Others observe this, question your rage, but you know you are right. You just need everyone to accept you are right, that your tea is fantastic, and can cure what ails ya. Why is no one falling for your fury?!

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat