close up of realistic dinosaur head in jungle

Having made my point about professionalism, I waited to see if Mr Thiessen would adjust his attitude, and thus make any kind of conversation/debate worth pursuing. His comment on my post contained a rare admission on his part that his behaviour is motivated by aggression, cowardice and pride, though he is also unrepentent in his approach. It therefore seems futile to continue any kind of debate or discussion over the subject of dating and science, but as I’d taken the time to write this all out, it would feel like a shame to waste that effort.

On to his response to me, let’s see what has upset him so much:

Sadly, there is a great deal if irony here. Mr Thiessen has not, to my knowledge, demonstrated his archaeological credentials, and spends a lot of his time merely repeating what others have previous written, adding nothing to it but mere opinion, something which shall become obvious during the course of his post. He vainly appeals to authority, yet offers little of substance, and he is quick to become aggressive if his argumetnts are contradicted or refuted.

Mr Thiessen goes on to quote this passage of mine:

Right, I should mention that this post has nothing to do with the science of romance! Nor I am not the best person to ask for dating advice! I’ve not been too sure how to classify this post, since it is also a response of sorts, and it might look at the problem of creationist pseudo-science as well.
What I instead refer to is how people date the past. Archaeologists – good ones at least – have a variety of tools at their disposal, and will use them to get a reasonable idea as to how old any given set of remains is. It does not give one hundred percent answers, but that doesn’t mean those answers should be rejected. Science is rarely about absolutes. In most fields, be it biology, chemistry or physics, we are constantly learning. New experiments lead conclusions both expected and unexpected, which in turn lead to new tests, which lead to new conclusions, and so on.

It is not without irony that he then issues the next few paragraphs…

The biggest irony is that Mr Thiessen accepts without hesitation or question, anything that validates his narrow, literal view of the Bible, and only attempts meaningful scrutiny of information and evidence that contradicts his view. Worse, he does not provide actual evidence for the flaws he alleges exists with the scientific method. He merely states that it has problems, and from there, demands that everyone is compliant with his belief on science. He has not carried out research, and is not qualified to lecture on the various subjects he has written about, yet thinks his arguments should be accepted without hesitation.

He fails to understand that my acceptance of information via the scientific method has not come about from rigid dogma, because the scientific method does not operate on a rigid dogma. The scientists who perform experiments of various kinds don’t ignore results they don’t like in order to force specific, preferred conclusions. Mr Thiessen on the other hand, demands that scientists ignore the results of impartial and neutral study, if those results do not align with his narrow vision. Who is therefore being blind?

The same is true with studying the past. We learn stuff that we might expect, and also that we don’t expect, but what we don’t do is throw the baby out with the bath water if an experiment yields something we didn’t expect, or for whatever reason, don’t like. (Ibid)

Further irony. A cursory look at both of Mr Thiessen’s sites shows he shares a lot of material purely to be objectionable, especially where his precious worldview is threatened. He didn’t like my post about dinosaurs, so he whinged. He didn’t like that I dared to criticise creationism and its faulty mindset, so he issued a lengthy, yet vapid response.

From here on, I am not going to quote Mr Thiessen’s post in its entirety (his rant is simply too long), however since I am not afraid of accountability, you can click the link to see his commentary in all its context.

Actually, no one started out with the premise that evolution is true. The first experiments, tests and studies would have been about discovery, and those initial experiments came back with evidence that life evolved, as opposed to springing forth via creationism. Subsequent experiments have continued to back up evolution. It is creationists who work backwards, and whilst Mr Thiessen may not like creationists referred to as dishonest, what other term works best? Misguided? Stupid? Ignorant? There certainly isn’t any great term for someone who seeks to throw out the vast majority of evidence, in order to force a conclusion.

Incorrect. My post about dinosaurs provided but one example of how dating systems work, and why they are a perfectly valid tool. If creationists are too lazy to understand them, that is their problem, just as it is on the creationist to stop being fearful of evidence.

Ah yes, let’s take a propaganda film as some great takedown of the system. We should naturally take Expelled as being above and beyond the decades – centuries – of hard work and endeavour that has got us where we are today.

Who knows, maybe Mr Thiessen means this film instead? It’s got the same degree of merit as his propaganda film!

As to the last paragraph, which will be the last one I will address, he should heed his own advice. Mr Thiessen routinely comments on science, but has not displayed any understanding of it. He repeats the Biblical narrative and does not consider any other viewpoint. He does not get to lecture others on being open-minded. He ought to keep quiet on matters he does not understand (thus demonstrating he can practice what he preaches), instead of expecting everyone to take him as an expert on any subject.

It is also worth noting that the concepts of evolution are backed up by other fields of study. Observations of the cosmos, our understanding of the speed of light and relativity, and other sciences, all provide evidence to support a universe and a world that is billions of years old. No one started out with this premise in mind, it is a conclusion reached by study.

There is an excellent post, found here, that I would advise Mr Thiessen to read. Whether he is prepared to be open-minded enough to absorb it is up to him.

Back to The Meerkat Responds

It is not without some extreme irony that in my recent back-and-forth with Citizen Tom, he bemoaned how Democrats champion science whilst not following it. Meanwhile, thanks to the rhetoric of RFK Jr, there is a surge in cases of the easily-preventable measles illness, an illness that can be crippling, not to mention deadly.

Anti-vax nonsense is dangerous. Whilst Tom and people like him may turn around to champion freedom of choice (which of course has nothing to do with the original argument about following the science), cases of this preventable disease are now at their highest levels for decades, and that’s entirely down to the anti-vax rubbish spread by the likes of RFK Jr. So much for Republicans valuing science.

It’s not just in the USA that measles is on the rise. There’s been an explosion in cases in the UK, as parents inexplicably ignore the science and follow the conspiracy theorists down the rabbit hole. Much of this misplaced fear is down to the anti-science crowd pedalling fear in the wake of conspiracies about the covid vaccines, despite a wealth of evidence that debunks these conspiracies.

Nothing is 100% safe, and there are people who cannot be vaccinated for one reason or another. This does not mean vaccines are not effective! Vaccines are why smallpox has been virtually eradicated. Vaccines keep dangerous diseases under control, so why is it that people champion the likes of RFK Jr, a man who ignores evidence and decidedly does not follow the science? Can someone make it make sense?

To briefly summarise:

Falling back onto the argument about parental choice does nothing to rebuke how Republicans are ignoring the science on this critical issue. The spread of measles in the USA is a damning indictment of their attitude. The spread of it in the UK is a damning indictment of the same mentality on these shores. No political entity can claim to be a party of science whilst allowing deadly illnesses to return and spread via debunked anti-vax rhetoric.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

It is said that governments around the world have protocols in place to handle first contact with an alien civilisation. Precisely what those protocols are is kept secret, and it is also said that there is no international consensus on what to do if an alien empire gets in touch. It may well be that such a pivotal event in human history would entirely depend on where aliens land, if they actually land anywhere at all.

So, what should we do as a species if we receive a transmission, or even a visit from an extra-terrestrial spacecraft?

Much of what we do may depend on what the aliens do. If they arrive with peaceful intentions, the bid should obviously be to establish communications, and to do with we’d need to find some form of common ground. The language of maths has often been spoken of as the obvious choice, as there are certain universal constants underpinned by maths. The same could be said of the laws of physics, the composition of the elements, and so on. These fields could be used as the basis for translating languages.

The key challenge would be in deciphering how an alien intelligence might think. In sci-fi, no matter how imaginative the writers, it is impossible to truly think like an other-worldly being. Would they experience emotions the way we do, if at all? Their concepts of culture, morality, politics, all of it would truly be alien to us, and our ways of thinking would be completely alien to them. Could we communicate, beyond rudimentary exchanges of obvious mathematical truths?

Assuming that we could connect to an alien intelligence in a substantial way, what then? If the contact is long-distance, with years between signals, it may be nothing more than an exchange of ideas and ideals. If by some amazing, terrifying set of circumstances we are visited upon by powerful alien spacecraft, we would then have to contend with the concept that we are not in control of the situation. Any alien species that could build ships capable of interstellar travel would have technology akin to magic in our eyes, and we would be at their mercy. This would be frightening for humanity, but if such a species were peaceful, we could yet find ourselves experiencing some tremendous revelations about the universe.

What may prove to be up for debate is precisely who is placed in charge of handling communications. If an alien ship landed in say, France, would it be right and just for the French to handle everything on behalf of the entire human race, or would we be better served by handing over these duties to the United Nations? What would the governments of say, the USA and Russia do if the aliens decided to establish an exclusive relationship with Japan or China? Again, we might not be in charge of proceedings, and that may not sit well with everyone.

If aliens arrived as would-be conquerors, we would face a simple choice. Surrender (assuming aliens would understand the gesture), or be rendered extinct. If they can get here, they’ll have technology that we simply could not compete with. The policies of world leaders in those circumstances would probably be to throw ordinary people under the bus, for the sake of striking deals, though again, would an alien intelligence even consider such a notion? It may even be that an advanced alien empire might view us in the same way we regard bacteria, and cleanse earth of humans, without so much as a single attempt to say hello.

I doubt we’ll find out how any of this goes within my lifetime. Part of me is dismayed by this, and part of me is pleased. First contact will be a turbulent time, no matter what happens.

Back to Meerkat Prompts

With apologies for the lengthy title, and with thanks to the evergreen Bruce Gerencser for providing the inspiration, in this post I’m delving into a murky realm, a place where facts meet with dogma, and the evidence around is challenged not by additional evidence, but with the unreliable element of human interpretation.

Bruce’s post highlights the problem of unhinged fanaticism overriding evidence and logic, and what’s worse, this was used to unreasonably persecute a teaching assistant who merely graded a student in accordance with the requirements of the test. The student had not followed guidelines and subsequently failed the test, but did not accept this outcome, protested under the unreasonable lines of ‘religious persecution’, and got the instructor suspended as a result. There is a serious case of entitlement on show here, and unfortunately this is far from an isolated case.

The expectation that facts should give way to indoctrination is not a problem unique to organised religion, but you can bet that organised religion is one of the chief driving forces behind eroding common sense educational needs, and it is certainly among the most powerful movements aimed at undermining good science. I have written before of the desire of some Christians to replace logic-driven, evidence-based teachings with rigid, literal interpretations of holy texts, and these rather close-minded fundamentalists do not stop to consider the cost of this. If we had kept to such blind devotion, humanity would never have escaped the Stone Age.

Our willingness to challenge, to learn, to observe and to study is why we have longer lifespans than ever before. It’s why we can survive injuries and illnesses that would have inevitably killed our ancestors. Now, some people might say ‘but you still can’t cheat death!’, but that would be beside the point. I am not saying we can render ourselves immortal and turn back entropy. However, that has nothing to do with how we are better placed to fight diseases and injuries.

Quality of life has improved too. If not for a willingness to learn, we would never have developed tools to make growing and preserving food easier. It would still take days to travel across a country, and weeks or months to travel between continents, assuming we could safely make the journey. What makes this all the more ironic is that the very people who are loudly decrying science, and bemoaning persecution, enjoy all the fruits of science, yet as sure as night follows day they will list out anything negative they can think of, without pausing to reflect that they throw the baby out with the bathwater in their little rants.

Can scientific endeavour be used for harm? Yes. Is that a reflection on science itself? No. What would do far more harm is to encourage deception in education. Letting irrelevant answers with no relevance to the topic take precedence over facts, logic and evidence does a lot more damage to our progress as a species, and to then whine of persecution? The irony is high, and the lack of self-awareness is even greater. You have to shake your head in disbelief at the cognitive disassociation on display.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

Depending on where you are in the world, there is a famous constellation in the night sky, known as Orion. This beautiful celestial arrangement of stars has been an important navigational aid to ancient travellers, and studies of the stars have taken place for hundreds of years.

There are a number of stars that can be considered to be famous within this constellation. Rigel is the brightest star – well, most of the time – and a candidate for a supernova. There are a couple of stellar systems made up of multiple stars. The one that tends to capture the imagination of the public the most is Betelgeuse.

Located at the left shoulder of Orion, this massive, evolved star is also a candidate for a supernova, and it is widely expected to be astronomically soon, though ‘soon’ could be anywhere from a few decades to a hundred thousand years. Observations of Betelgeuse have revealed all sorts of hints as to its past, and clues as to its future. Emission lines, comparisons to other stars, and our understanding of physics have built a good, albeit imperfect picture of this gargantuan beast.

The first major detail to note is that Betelgeuse has moved off the main sequence of solar evolution. It is no longer fusing hydrogen into helium at its core, and has moved from being a blue giant star, to a red supergiant. Studies of the interstellar medium around the star have yielded estimates that it’s spent 40,000 years in its current state. Betelgeuse certainly lives up to the term supergiant, with a radius between 640 and 764 times that of the Sun. To give a clearer idea of what that means, if it were placed in our solar system, Betelgeuse would engulf all four of the inner planets! Then again, it isn’t necessarily that simple, as massive stars like Betelgeuse don’t tend to have a so-easily defined surface, and their properties render them irregular in shape.

Hubble images showing the pulsations of Betelgeuse. By Alex Lobel, Andrea Dupree, Ronald Gilliland, CfA, STScI, NASA, ESA – https://www.cfa.harvard.edu/news/archive/alobelimg.html, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=5829202

Another key detail of Betelgeuse, and further evidence of its instability, is that it varies in brightness. Whilst Rigel is usually the brightest star in Orion, Betelgeuse can occasionally outshine it during its more excitable moments. Betelgeuse also exhibits high mass loss, and the surrounding medium around the star is a region enriched by its solar wind, placing Betelgeuse in a bubble of hot gas. In effect, the system is a seething cauldron, a maelstrom of churning radiation and superheated stellar material.

The star’s future is going to be dramatic, though the details of precisely when Betelgeuse will blow itself apart are uncertain. Every dimming, every pulsation, and every fluctuation is treated by the media as a sign that a supernova is imminent. The reality – as annoying as it may be from an amateur enthusiast’s perspective – is that Betelgeuse probably has many thousands of years to go before it blows. Nonetheless, this has not stopped speculation, with various computer models of the explosion suggesting Betelgeuse would become as bright as the half-Moon for a few months, possibly brighter still, and would even be visible in daylight.

Following this event, the likely remnant would be a neutron star, as Betelgeuse is not thought to have enough mass to form a black hole. Whilst this would be a powerful, exotic object, I don’t think it would be visible from earth. Orion would lose one of its key components, and the night sky would be forever changed.

It’s a humbling thought to think that one day, this will happen. It would be amazing to bear witness to it when it does.

Back to The Meerkat of Science!

Perhaps this post would belong to a science fiction setting, but there is an overlap with scientific ideas, and a dash of idealism as well. The original concept has been popularised in sci-fi for decades, and subsequently explored by scientists, but so far it remains a dream, and something of a long reach too.

At present, we explore both the solar system and the wider universe via satellites, telescopes and probes. Direct human exploration of the cosmos is out of our reach, owing to the incredible distances between stellar bodies, even within the solar system. It is believed to take between six and nine months for humans to reach Mars, one of the closest celestial bodies to earth, and this is when the two planets are at their closest approach, a distance of 56 million kilometres. To traverse the outer solar system would take years, even decades, placing human flight more or less off-limits, and that is to say nothing of extra-solar missions.

Reaching our nearest Neighbour

Proxima Centauri is a red dwarf star, some 4.24 light-years from our sun. To put it another way, it is 40.17 trillion kilometres away. The fastest human-made object, the Parker Solar Probe, would take over 7,000 years to travel that distance, whilst the Voyager probes would take 77,000 years. These are clearly not timescales that work for direct human exploration! The question becomes, what might we be able to do about it?

The short answer is: nothing. We lack the technology to do much other than point telescopes at distant stars, and collect evidence about the universe from there. Our present understanding of physics, space and time suggest that faster-than-light travel is impossible, and will always be impossible.

Is this a somewhat beguiling, frustrating observation? Yes. The notion that the wider universe will forever be off-limits to humanity, save for lengthy sleeper missions (which are not without serious technical challenges of their own), is depressing. We are a curious species, and we want to get out there. We want to see and observe the fascinating sights of the Milky Way. It would be incredible to see another star system up close, and even more amazing to walk on an alien world. To think that we may never be able to do that is not a happy thought.

Speculative Suggestions

Despite the lack of evidence for FTL being possible, this has not stopped some scientists from theorising, and going as far as to do the math, so to speak, on a couple of concepts. The Alcubierre Drive is one such idea, which proposes warping space/time to create a bubble around a ship (not too dissimilar to Star Trek’s famous warp drive). A static form of this idea, in the shape of a Krasnikov Tube, has also been developed, which from this meerkat’s limited understanding suggests some form of wormhole.

The problem with both ideas is a reliance of vast quantities of as-yet unproven exotic matter, with negative energy density. Again, I not profess to understand the detailed nature of these devices, but I understand enough to know they present major hinderances to the concepts.

Wormholes – another idea rendered popular in sci-fi – have been proposed as a theoretical means of getting somewhere faster. Their existence remains unproven, but the theories suggest there are a number of means by which they could exist. The problem would rest in finding them, and relying on them to link regions that would be of value to humans (such as star systems with habitable worlds).

What about UFOs?

Proponents of UFOs being alien spacecraft might argue that these craft have reached earth from distant worlds, and done so using advanced technology to travel faster than light. There is absolutely no way to verify this in any way shape or form, and some theories suggest that our possible alien visitors are coming to earth from another dimension, which would bypass the question of FTL completely. Nonetheless, this is another persistent idea in the argument that FTL is possible.

What is more clear is that, at this moment in time, travelling faster than light in a way that doesn’t violate the laws of nature is beyond human understanding. We may cling to hope, even a fool’s hope, but’s what’s wrong with daring to dream?

Back to The Meerkat of Science!

The beautiful forests of Alberta, Canada, hid a secret. Under the rich landscape are thousands of fossils, dating back 72 million years, to the Cretaceous Period, the final epoch of the dinosaurs. What makes this location so remarkable is that the remains are all from the same species, the Pachyrhinosaurus (related to the Triceratops). How did so many of these powerful creatures perish, all in one place?

The prevailing theory, based on the available evidence (and therefore a reasonable assumption) is that a flash flood caught out a migrating herd. The climate of the region was warmer and wetter 72 million years ago, with conditions allowing for the possibility. Unfortunately for so many Pachyrhinosaurs, the possibility became reality, and they were caught up in a torrent they had no chance of avoiding. Worse, they were not especially good in water, being large, heavyset creatures.

This acts as an intriguing reminder that nature can and has enacted devastating disasters, even in prehistoric times. The study of this also highlights the amazing work of palaeontology, and the incredible efforts of scientists and their tools. To unveil the past like this takes dedication, persistence, and years of patience. Discovering what happened on our planet millions of years ago is an astonishing achievement, a testament to what we are capable of as a species, when we are not bogged down by dogma and ignorance.

Back to Meerkat Prompts

In the realm of healthcare, there are some reasonable certainties (such as how cleaning wounds can prevent infection, and the effectiveness of vaccines). Well-established guidance on the treatment of illnesses and injuries has saved millions of lives throughout history. The fields of chemistry and biology have become increasingly advanced, and whilst this is not always without risk, the development of medical technology continues to save and improve lives. Why then, do some people place their faith in a man with little understanding of any of this?

Robert F Kennedy Jr, the man appointed as Health Secretary by Donald Trump, is an anti-vaxxer, and he is also someone who would eat roadkill, who swims in rivers known to be contaminated with sewage and sources of disease, and and he once had a parasitic worm in his brain, quite possibly from eating undercooked pork or eggs (the most common form of transmission).

Kennedy has repeated long-debunked claims about vaccines causing autism, and about fluoride in water supplies. He has made misleading claims about covid-19. With so many easily-rebuked claims about medical care, how is it that somehow, he is still entrusted with making medical policy for hundreds of millions of people? There is a major vacuum of common sense here, a demonstration of how someone woefully ill-equipped to do a job can land a job, provided they know the right people, or repeat the right mantra. The only area I would agree with him on is about processed foods, and even then, there would be caveats.

The US healthcare system has been broken for decades, for it has been a system that has prioritised money over health, and now it is headed by someone who does not even understand the basics of health, and that someone has been appointed by someone who thinks money is more important than anything else. No wonder the system there is so broken, and it will take a miracle to fix it. The opposition to nationalised healthcare services seen all over the world has to be rooted in the most narrow-minded of thinking.

Back to The Thinking ‘Kat

A short while ago, I wrote a Meerkat Prompt regarding UFOs, and pondered the fanciful logic required to accept the idea of alien craft visiting earth. This is not to say I regard aliens as not being out there, because in this vast universe, with more galaxies than grains of sand on planet earth, and billions upon billions of stars and planets, it seems inevitable there must be more than merely humanity.

Of course, believing in alien life, even accepting the idea as a probable likelihood, is not same as knowing. As astronomers look to the cosmos, studying all sorts of fascinating phenomena, is the faint possibility of discovering evidence of alien life always on their minds? For some researchers, it’s an active field of study, a hunt as it were, and that hunt might – might – have yielded results.

K2-18b is located 124 light years away, one of numerous exoplanets in the Milky Way. It is approximately 2.5 times the size of earth, but nonetheless its size means it’s highly likely to be a rocky planet. Observations from the James Webb Space Telescope have revealed signs of a chemical signature that, on earth at least, is produced via only one mechanism: life. Two chemicals – dimethyl sulphide and dimethyl disulphide – produced by bacteria and marine phytoplankton on earth, have been detected in abundance in K2-18b’s atmosphere, leading to the possibility of a world teeming with life. Scientists are quick – and right – to point out that the evidence is not an absolutely certainty, but there is more confidence in the evidence than there has previously been.

If there is life on this distant world, then it would certainly have an impact on humanity. How might it alter our perception of ourselves, and our place in the universe? On the other hand, the presence of bacteria and plankton might not be taken as exceptional by some, even if confirmed. Still, definitive evidence of life on other planets would show the persistence of evolutionary processes, hinting at a universal constant. It would add motivation to the desire to explore the galaxy. It would lend itself to the idea that other, more sophisticated forms of life are out there.

More powerful, sensitive telescopes are in development, that will be able to probe the atmospheres of exoplanets in greater detail. These new telescopes will be able to tell us much more about the worlds we know are out there, and might provide more conclusive answers. In the meantime, it is certainly exciting to think we might have found evidence of alien life.

Back to The Meerkat of Science

Space is filled with fascinating stars. There are diminutive red dwarves, there are stars like our own sun, that spin in orbit around each other. You have stars that are so large they would engulf Jupiter and even Saturn, if placed within our solar system. You have stars that shine brighter than a thousand sun-type companions. There are so many incredible, wondrous stars in the cosmos, that it is difficult to know which one to honour first, but I thought I’d take a look at a unique, turbulent binary system, the system of Eta Carinae.

By Jon Morse (University of Colorado) & NASA Hubble Space Telescope – Hubble Site [1], Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=3971388

The earliest firm record of Eta Carinae comes from Edmond Halley, who noted the star’s position in 1677, though it’s possible that references to a bright star in the southern hemisphere are in fact references to Eta Carinae. The star shot to fame within the astronomical world due to two huge eruptions, made the star easy to spot in the night sky. The Great Eruption, in the middle of the 19th Century, and the Lesser Eruption, in 1890, may not be the only occasions that Eta Carinae has produced powerful stellar explosions, though the observational history of these events is hard to pin down.

What isn’t hard to pin down is the erratic nature of Eta Carinae.

A True Giant

An X-ray image of Eta Carinae. By NASA/CXC/GSFC/K.Hamaguchi, et al. – http://www.chandra.harvard.edu/photo/2014/etacar/etacar_lg.jpg, Public Domain, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=35012902

The primary star, Eta Carinae A, is believed to weigh in at 100 solar masses, placing it in the high end mass category. There are more massive stars out there, but not many, and certainly not many that can be observed in as much detail. The precise details of Eta Carinae A are proving difficult to determine, thanks to the huge plumes of ejected gas and material from the earlier eruptions, but scientists have pieced together enough to make some reasonable conclusions of the primary star’s mass, and they have also been able to determine that this is a star on the edge.

In previous posts, I mentioned that stars are a balancing act between the fusion at their cores, and the force of gravity. These two competing forces form an equilibrium, and in the end, gravity wins when the star runs out of fuel to sustain fusion. In the case of Eta Carinae A, the forces at work in the core are so powerful, they have brought the star to the brink of the Eddington Limit.

The Eddington Limit is the theoretical point at which the power within the star exceeds the pressure of the gravity bearing down. If this limit is breached, the star will lose material in powerful explosions. Such is the turbulent energy churning away within Eta Carinae A, that it is thought to have touched this limit, and at times, barely held itself together. The star is unstable, and there is evidence that the internal structure of the star has not fully recovered from its prior outbursts.

Complicating the evolution of the primary star is the presence of a secondary star, about which less is known. Eta Carinae B is believed to be quite massive in its own right, anywhere from 30 to 80 solar masses, and it has a strong, fast solar wind, which creates a channel in the wind of the primary as it orbits. This orbit is highly irregular, and thus the secondary star will be alternately stretching and compressing the primary. Needless to say, this has a serious effect on the evolution of the primary!

The Future

Eta Carinae A is going to explode as a spectacular supernova in the astronomically near future, and there is speculation that it could be so powerful, it deserves a category of its own, namely a hypernova. The explosion could rip through the previously ejected material, and light up the Carina Nebula, where the star resides. How this impacts Eta Carinae B is unclear, though the most likely outcome is for the secondary star to be roughly and quickly ejected from the system. It’s widely believed that Eta Carinae A has enough mass to collapse into a black hole, and thus could offer us a glimpse into the process of black hole formation.

When might all this happen? Well, it is hard to say. Direct observations of the stars are impossible at the present time. Eta Carinae A is known to be unstable, and prone to violent outbursts. Astronomers have seen other stars display similar eruptions, and those stars have blown themselves up a few years later. On the other hand, it’s been more than 150 years since the Great Eruption, and the star is still with us. Such massive stars are rare, and therefore there’s a lot we haven’t yet observed of their behaviour. This can make definitive predictions of their futures challenging. Nonetheless, what we can be reasonably certain of is that Eta Carinae A will provide an incredible picture when it finally does go supernova, and the possibility cannot be ruled out that this might be soon!

Back to The Meerkat of Science!