Skip to content
Menu
Meerkat Musings
  • Welcome to Meerkat Musings
  • Meerkat Podcasts
  • Why Meerkats?
  • Formula 1
  • Why I love…
  • What I think…
  • Sci-Fi Analysis
  • Reviews
  • Meerkat Fiction
  • Meerkat Book Reviews
  • Sites Meerkats Like
  • Site Updates
Meerkat Musings

Common Trekkie Arguments

Tweet
Follow me
There are a number of popular arguments that Pro-Trek debaters have made, and continue to make, when arguing that the Federation would defeat the Empire. Here’s a selection of them…
​
1. Imperial vessels look old, and in no way sleek or modern. Federation ships are therefore much more advanced.
​
Looks aren’t everything. A modern cruise liner looks a lot nicer and more modern than an AEGIS cruiser- I know which one would sink the other though. Imperial ships are designed for function- and that function is war. Who cares if they have fancy shiny controls or sleek aerodynamic designs? These things are not relevant where war is concerned.
​
2. Why is this about the Federation vs the Empire? Wouldn’t the Klingons, Romulans etc help?
Why would they? Did the Alpha Quadrant band together to fight the Dominion, who represented the biggest threat to them all bar the Borg? No, they didn’t- the Cardassians joined the Dominion, the Romulans had to be tricked into taking part on the Allies’ side, and the Breen later also joined the Dominion. A number of empires declared themselves neutral too- the Gorn and the Tholians spring to mind.
​
So there’s no reason to assume everyone would rally round to fight the Empire, although even if they did, it would not affect the outcome of a war.
​​
3. Q would help the Federation. For that matter, so would any number of super-beings within the Milky Way.​
​
Like they did when the Federation was threatened by the Borg, or the Dominion? They have never intervened to help, even when the problem was caused by them (Q introduced the Federation to the Borg, remember).
Furthermore, if Q did help, how is this a sign that the Federation can defeat the Empire? This is a copout- relying on super-beings to win, because the Federation can’t hope to.
​​
4. In the TNG episode ‘The Outrageous Okuna’, Picard scoffs at laser weaponry, claiming it wouldn’t even penetrate their navigational shields. Since the Empire uses turbolasers, this means Imperial weapons would be useless against Federation shields.
​
This argument falls prey to the ‘no limits fallacy’. It assumes that because Picard made no specific mention of the power of laser weaponry, it doesn’t matter how powerful the laser is- Federation shields can resist it. This is of course wrong.
Firstly, energy has to go somewhere. This is one of the cardinal rules of thermodynamics- energy cannot be destroyed or created. Lets say the Enterprise can withstand 70TJ of energy before her shields fail. Lets say she is hit by a laser carrying 700TJ of energy. That’s ten times the energy her shields can handle. If you listen to the ‘no laser’ crowd, 630TJ of energy just mysteriously disappears. We have never seen or heard of the Federation possessing the ability to make energy disappear.
​
Secondly, where does Picard say that no laser, of any type or power, is useless against Federation ships? It’s clear he is referring only to the weaponry he is immediately facing. A fact made all the clearer by how other lasers later on are effective.
​
The Borg cutting laser, as seen in both ‘Q Who’ and ‘Best of Both Worlds’, is described as a laser by Worf, a trained tactical officer, and this weapon is very effective.
​
Finally, why assume turbolasers from Star Wars have to be like real lasers? They can be seen, which means they travel slower than light- whereas a laser is part of the electromagnetic spectrum, and would travel at the speed of light, thus not being visible.
​​
5. The Federation has advanced technology that the Empire lacks, such as holodecks, replicators, and transporters.
​
So what? Holodecks are usually used for recreational purposes, and whilst they can be used for training purposes it’s not like the Empire would lack training facilities- they possess a million star systems! They could easily have entire worlds devoted to training troops.
​
Replicators are convenient, but they hardly change the balance of military power. Their usefulness in that respect is quite low.
​
Transporters would allow for the rapid deployment of troops, but they cannot get through shields, and magnetic fields (even low-level ones that occur naturally, or even simply thick rock or metals) can interfere with them. Imperial ships use jamming as a matter of routine, so there is no guarantee that they would work at all.
​
6. The Rebellion defeated the Empire, and they only hand a few dozen ships! Surely if such a paltry force could beat the Empire, the Federation could too!
​
The Rebels have ships that are of the same technological base as the Empire’s, and they didn’t defeat the Empire in open battle. They fought a guerrilla war, and attacked only when they thought they had the element of surprise. They ‘beat’ the Empire by killing the Emperor, and because the Emperor did not have an official heir, the Empire fell into infighting and civil war with several factions vying for power. Add to this mix the Rebellion continuing to sow seeds of disarray and with (if the end of the Special Edition of ‘Return of the Jedi’ is anything to go by) multiple worlds in open revolt, the Empire fell apart.
The Federation cannot hope to achieve this feat.
Back to Star Trek vs Star Wars

2 thoughts on “Common Trekkie Arguments”

  1. The Emperor of Mankind says:
    August 17, 2014 at 12:17 pm

    Of course all of them would fall to the vastly superior forces of the Imperium of Mankind as the Emperor’s Astartes re-integrate his lost sons back into the Imperium. Of course those who stand in his way would be suitably dealt with

    Reply
    1. DarthTimon says:
      August 17, 2014 at 1:13 pm

      And they would fall swiftly to the Culture (who make Death Stars look like childrens’ toys). And the Doctor would kill them all anyways 😛

      Reply

Leave a Reply to DarthTimon Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

The Awakening UK

The Awakening USA

Please like and follow this meerkat!

Facebook
Facebook
fb-share-icon
Twitter
Visit Us
Follow Me
Tweet
YouTube
Follow by Email

Meerkat Comments

  • The Meerkat Muse – 26/01/2021 – Meerkat Musings on Football Manager 2021 – A New Beginning
  • Football Manager 21 P3 – Reaching for the Stars – Meerkat Musings on Football Manager 21 P4 – Upwards?
  • Football Manager 21 P4 – Upwards? – Meerkat Musings on Football Manager 21 P3 – Reaching for the Stars
  • DarthTimon on The Livejournal Days
  • Ariel Lynn on The Livejournal Days

Meerkat Tweets

Ben BerwickFollow

Ben Berwick
darth_timonBen Berwick@darth_timon·
2h

Hear hear! Johnson's never cared.

Michael🌱 Ⓥ #FBPE@changed_gear

@krishgm He asking us to ignore the missed COBRA meetings, encouragement to shake hands with Covid patients, a lamentable test & trace, holidays during the crisis, sporting events left uncanceled, ignoring science & repeatedly locking down late. Otherwise, he's done everything he could.

Reply on Twitter 1354361250973708293Retweet on Twitter 1354361250973708293Like on Twitter 13543612509737082933Twitter 1354361250973708293
darth_timonBen Berwick@darth_timon·
3h

Marina's been a brilliant beacon for women everywhere, what have you done?

Richnisss@RagsToRichnisss

@Marina_Sirtis Freedom from what? Lol we aren't even sure how effective these will be long term. Your posts are so ridiculous. I dont get why people act like you were some important role in star trek tng....literally ANYONE else could have played your role. You haven't been on much else lol

Reply on Twitter 1354342220283965442Retweet on Twitter 1354342220283965442Like on Twitter 1354342220283965442Twitter 1354342220283965442
darth_timonBen Berwick@darth_timon·
4h

Correct Ted. You desire conformity, as the right typically does.

Ted Cruz@tedcruz

We are the Borg. There is only one view. Any contrary view does not exist, or must be assimilated.

Journalism does not exist. Only orthodoxy. And conformity. https://twitter.com/thedailybeast/status/1353835608964292609

Reply on Twitter 1354324163280986113Retweet on Twitter 1354324163280986113Like on Twitter 1354324163280986113Twitter 1354324163280986113
darth_timonBen Berwick@darth_timon·
4h

#BorisHasFailedTheNation #Conservatives #ToryIncompetence @Conservatives

Reply on Twitter 1354323699244085250Retweet on Twitter 1354323699244085250Like on Twitter 13543236992440852501Twitter 1354323699244085250
darth_timonBen Berwick@darth_timon·
14h

So far, so good as far as #StarTrekLowerDecks is concerned!

Reply on Twitter 1354175082395037696Retweet on Twitter 1354175082395037696Like on Twitter 13541750823950376962Twitter 1354175082395037696
Load More...

Meerkat Categories

  • Art
  • Books
  • Charity
  • Family
  • Fiction
  • Film
  • Food
  • Football
  • Formula 1
  • Games
  • History
  • Interwebs
  • Music
  • Other Stuff
  • Politics
  • Religion
  • Reviews
  • Sci Fi
  • Science
  • Site News
  • Society
  • Technology
  • TV
  • Uncategorized
  • Weird
  • Work

Meerkat Podcasts

Meerkat Musings
Meerkat Musings
A man (meerkat?) called Ben discusses the world!

Podcast Subscription Menu

  • Visit Website
  • RSS Feed
Absolute Power
by Ben Berwick

Does absolute power corrupt absolutely?

Absolute Power
Absolute Power
January 23, 2021
Ben Berwick
Football Manager 2021 – The New Career P1
January 23, 2021
Ben Berwick
Favourite Day of the Week
January 17, 2021
Ben Berwick
Meerkat Musings on 2021!
January 8, 2021
Ben Berwick
Grosjean's Fiery Escape
November 30, 2020
Ben Berwick
Tea vs Coffee!
November 28, 2020
Ben Berwick
Musings on Cats
November 24, 2020
Ben Berwick
Mistakes and Anxiety
October 27, 2020
Ben Berwick
Trumped by Covid
October 2, 2020
Ben Berwick
Covid Conspiracies!
September 25, 2020
Ben Berwick
Search Results placeholder
©2021 Meerkat Musings | WordPress Theme by Superbthemes.com